Current Edition

From the Editor
Seen and Heard
Worldview
Misconceptions
Barriers to Protection
America's Drug Problem
Corruption in the Water
A Questionable Partnership
A HAVEN in the City
Masthead
Advisory Board

Online Extras

From the Founders
Past Editors
PH Alumni Network
Disclaimer

Home  About PH   Archive   Write   Subscribe   Advertise   Letters to Editor 

(Page 5 of 5)

But our options were drying up. I approached the priest with a written contract that would allow me to maintain control over the treatment system, and would put the group of citizens in charge of the day-to-day operations, but he refused to sign the contract. The cistern was permanently installed in the ground, so we couldn’t just pick up and start over somewhere else. I considered selling the system to the priest and building a new system in another area of the island, but I knew that if I participated in the Padre Jhonny’s corrupt plan, people in Muisne would not trust any other system that I later constructed.

Needless to say, I was upset about what was coming of all the time and money I had invested in the construction. But I wasn’t the only one who was angry. As word spread about Padre Jhonny’s determination to profit from the people of Muisne, people began to talk about removing the priest from his post. But rather than go through the bureaucratic hierarchy of the Catholic Church, the angry citizens considered starting a riot, and forcibly removing the priest from power. This was not a better option, in my view, than abandoning the system altogether. It would have alienated me and my project from many people in Muisne and the rest of the province, and I would have turned into a troublemaker instead of someone who genuinely wanted to improve the health of the residents of Muisne.

There was one final alternative. Several locals who had worked on the project traveled with me to the provincial capital, Esmeraldas, to confer with the bishop in charge of the province. I explained my situation to him, and he promised to support me. He signed a letter that essentially commanded Padre Jhonny to sign the contracted I had originally presented to him. He later signed it—grudgingly—while muttering critical comments as he did so.

A few days later, we finished constructing the treatment system. I tested the first batch of water, and the results revealed no E. coli or general coliforms. This was the first water produced in Muisne to be completely free of bacteria.

Muisne’s drinking water faces many problems, from the individual bacteria and parasites, to the high water table and sandy soil, to the dearth of education about domestic water hygiene. But of all the challenges I faced, the political system was the most difficult for me to surmount. Currently, a group of concerned citizens distributes water from the church every day. Several weeks ago, Muisne’s nuns along with several local church goers successfully deposed Padre Jhonny. A new priest is now in charge of Muisne’s church and has been supportive of the treatment system. But the treatment system still rests in a town controlled by the mayor, Jhonny’s cousin, and there are still people in the town who hope to profit from the treatment system. Politics was the greatest threat to the completion of my project, and continues to be the greatest threat to its proper implementation.

Since returning from Ecuador this fall, I have formed a non-profit organization to raise funds so that I can continue constructing other treatment systems in areas around Muisne. As I consider expanding my project, I often think about how to cope with problems I may encounter with local officials later on. Although I think my initial success in Muisne will win me some credibility, since many people have started to use the water and neighboring towns have sent delegations to ask for similar treatment systems in their towns, I know this will be a fight that I will always have to face. If it’s not a problem with Padre Jhonny, I will probably have difficulty dealing with a government official. Outside of Ecuador also, I now realize that any public health project that I or anyone takes on will inevitably have to deal with the political as well as the scientific. And the politics can easily do a scientifically-sound project in.



Alex Harding is a senior History major in Branford College at Yale University.

<<Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5

Hurricane Katrina Webzine
March 2007

P.H. presents

New Orleans: The Long Road to Recovery Special Webzine
More>>

This webzine features:

Waterproof Health Care
Building a Better, Stronger Health Care Infrastructure in New Orleans

A Storm in the Mind
Hurricane Katrina's Effects on the Mental Health System of New Orleans

Unstable Foundations
The Future of New Orleans Public Housing

Interview with Dr. Nancy Mock
Rebuilding a New Orleans Community with Good Food & Music: The Tremé Table Project